She Strengthens

The Ultimate Grilled Cheese Experience: Elevating a Classic

Imagine sinking your teeth into a perfectly toasted, melty, and savory grilled cheese sandwich that instantly transports you back to your childhood. This comforting classic is not just for kids; with the right ingredients, it can be a gourmet delight. Chef Adrienne Cheatham, a cheese aficionado, shares her expert ranking of the best cheeses for melting, from good to sublime.

The Foundation of a Perfect Grilled Cheese

While the bread and spread are crucial, the cheese is the star of the show. Cheatham emphasizes that the right cheese can make all the difference in creating a truly amazing grilled cheese experience.

Cheese Rankings: From Good to Exceptional

11. Manchego: A favorite for snacking, but not ideal for melting due to its pronounced flavor and texture at room temperature. However, if you’re a Manchego enthusiast, you can still create a decent sandwich.

10. Muenster: Melts well, but loses flavor in the process. Its great texture makes it suitable for hot sandwiches with other ingredients, but not ideal for a basic grilled cheese.

9. Raclette: A well-balanced cheese with a subtle, creamy quality. It melts nicely and pairs well with other ingredients, making it perfect for grilled sandwiches.

8. Provolone: Underrated and deserving of more attention, Provolone offers a mild, nutty flavor and excellent melting properties. Stack multiple slices for a cheesy, stretchy delight.

7. Monterey Jack: A melting master, Monterey Jack is perfect for grilled cheese. For an extra kick, try pepper Jack for added flavor.

6. Fontina: A champion melter, Fontina is delicious on its own or paired with acidic ingredients like tomato or cornichon.

5. Gruyere: A go-to for melted cheese dishes, Gruyere melts beautifully and boasts amazing flavor. Start with a low pan temperature to prevent burning the bread.

4. Comté: If you love Gruyere but want more flavor, Comté is an excellent alternative.

3. Taleggio: A true grilled cheese star, Taleggio offers a range of varieties to suit your taste. Its flavor becomes subtle when melted, providing a beautiful balance.

2. American Cheese: A childhood favorite, American cheese melts easily and tastes creamy. It may not be refined, but it’s a classic for a reason.

1. Mild Cheddar: The winner of Cheatham’s cheese ranking, mild cheddar brings the perfect melt and flavor. Let it shine on its own, and you’ll be rewarded with a truly exceptional grilled cheese experience.